The Comfort of James Herriot’s Stories

All Crea­tures Great & Small, Mas­ter­piece The­ater, PBS

I don’t know if you are watch­ing All Crea­tures Great and Small on Mas­ter­piece The­ater on PBS these Sun­day nights, but if you’re not, you are miss­ing some­thing wonderful.

All Crea­tures Great and Small is a col­lec­tion of sto­ries told by vet­eri­nar­i­an James Her­riot. (Her­riot is his pen name, actu­al­ly — James Alfred White was his real name.) His sto­ries of car­ing for the ani­mals in York­shire, Britain, are filled with gen­tle wis­dom, pro­found moments, and won­der­ful char­ac­ters (human and not.) 

This lat­est ren­di­tion of the show (there have been many over the last 50 years) came out in Britain last spring and was a run­away pan­dem­ic hit. We in the U.S. get it now. Tis balm for the soul, I’m telling you.

As NBCnews.com put it: [T]he real rea­son this show is des­tined to be a hit all over again is the gen­tle­ness of its premise, and the small­ness of its dra­mas. These are not sto­ries that span con­ti­nents or gen­er­a­tions. Ten­sion is found in two cats acci­den­tal­ly put back in the wrong cages, or cows suf­fer­ing from milk fever.

Sweet relief — give me more Gen­tle­ness of Premise and Small­ness of Dra­ma, I say! Beau­ti­ful land­scapes, won­der­ful accents, great char­ac­ters, and grace-filled kind­ness fill these sto­ries. The Mas­ter­piece pro­duc­tion is gor­geous and it has sent me back to the sto­ries themselves.

I have a vivid mem­o­ry of read­ing James Her­riot sto­ries to #1 Son. A severe asth­mat­ic, #1 Son’s ear­ly years fea­tured sev­er­al fright­en­ing res­pi­ra­to­ry episodes. He was hos­pi­tal­ized a cou­ple of times and kept out of the hos­pi­tal sev­er­al more times by a ded­i­cat­ed doc­tor will­ing to give us emer­gency treat­ment in her office, let­ting us hang out until he was stable.

Complete Tales of Winnie-the-PoohThose were years in which I car­ried a “sto­ry­book” in my purse/bag — some­thing longer than a tra­di­tion­al pic­ture book, a “long book” as #1 Son called it, with sev­er­al sto­ries housed in sep­a­rate chap­ters. Pip­pi Long­stock­ing, Nar­nia, Pooh, and the like. I car­ried such books just in case…just in case we sud­den­ly found our­selves in the doctor’s office all day or the emer­gency room.

The year he was in kinder­garten #1 Son left for school one after­noon at 12:30 with a run­ny nose — spring aller­gies — and when he arrived home on the bus less than three hours lat­er I had to car­ry him inside and was faced with the deci­sion of whether to call an ambu­lance or some­how get him to the hos­pi­tal on my own — quick­ly. I opt­ed for the lat­ter and still some­times won­der if I would make that same deci­sion if I had to do it over again.

He was admit­ted to the hos­pi­tal that time, “a very sick boy” the ER doc­tor said so omi­nous­ly I thought my heart stopped. He wore a mask that deliv­ered oxy­gen and med­ica­tion 247. The steroids that nor­mal­ly wired him when they kicked in didn’t — he was so sick. He lay in the hos­pi­tal bed with his eyes closed, the hum of the neb­u­liz­er the only sound in the room. My hus­band and I shuf­fled his baby sis­ter around with grand­par­ent help and took turns stay­ing with him.

James Herriot's Treasury for ChildrenOne morn­ing I was there with him and in an effort to have some sound that was not med­ical I began read­ing the “long book” in my bag: James Herriot’s Trea­sury for Chil­dren.

I think it may be the very best book I could’ve read dur­ing that fright­en­ing time. Our copy has beau­ti­ful illus­tra­tions, but #1 Son was too sick to view them. I lay in the bed with him and read aloud these sweet sto­ries of ani­mals and their peo­ple. We had/have no pets — ani­mal dan­der being one of the biggest asth­ma trig­gers for three in our fam­i­ly. But our kids always loved sto­ries of animals.

But most­ly I read those sto­ries in the hos­pi­tal for me, if I’m hon­est. My baby was asleep or too sick to pay atten­tion. But those sto­ries of such gen­tle premise, such small dra­ma, helped my Mama-heart beat a bit stead­ier, a lit­tle slow­er, more sure. could breathe eas­i­er while I read them and it gave me hope his breath would come eas­i­er soon. So I read over the sound of the neb­u­liz­er until I was hoarse.

When the first episode of All Crea­tures Great and Small start­ed a cou­ple of weeks ago, I texted #1 Son, a healthy, strap­ping young man whose asth­ma sel­dom both­ers any­more, and asked if he remem­bered read­ing the Her­riot sto­ries. He did not — he remem­bers lit­tle of that hos­pi­tal­iza­tion and I don’t think we read them again, for what­ev­er rea­son. But as the open­ing cred­its rolled, my eyes filled with tears and my heart was full of grat­i­tude for Dr. “Her­riot” and his stories.

If you find your­self in need of sim­ple com­fort, some delight and beau­ty deliv­ered with small dra­ma and gen­er­ous kind­ness, do check out All Crea­tures Great and Small. Per­fect for these ongo­ing pan­dem­ic days….

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

16 Comments
Oldest
Newest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
candice ransom
candice ransom
3 years ago

Heav­en knows we can all use all the com­fort we can get, Melanie. I so loved this essay because it shows the true pow­er of read­ing, no mat­ter what the sto­ry, or the cir­cum­stances. I car­ry a book with me every­where and read stand­ing in line at the post office, wait­ing in doc­tors’ offices, in the movie the­ater dur­ing com­mer­cials and com­ing attrac­tions (with very lit­tle light). Most peo­ple “kill” time with their phones. I use books to keep me calm, cen­tered, and enter­tained. I haven’t watched the Her­riot shows, old or new, but I am get­ting that lus­cious trea­sury of sto­ries. When the new… Read more »

sarmarienelson
3 years ago

I love this essay, Melanie. And thank you for the series rec­om­men­da­tion – sim­ple com­fort and gen­er­ous kind­ness are cer­tain­ly things we can all use right now!

David LaRochelle
3 years ago

You make a strong case for the series, and the books, Melanie! I’ll have to check to see if Gary can get the on his TV.

Sarah Sullivan
3 years ago

What a love­ly essay, Melanie! And, I could­n’t agree with you more. I just keep watch­ing these new episodes over and over again. They are absolute­ly wonderful!

Susan Latta
Susan Latta
3 years ago

Melanie, thank you for this. Wow. I too am enjoy­ing the shows, and sit there with a smile on my face for the whole episode. I nev­er read the book, but think I will now. You are so right in say­ing they are balm for the soul!

April Halprin Wayland
3 years ago

Melanie, thank you for gen­er­ous­ly shar­ing this slice of your life that was fright­en­ing. Read­ing a “real” book calms me, too. Read­ing your post fills me with love.

Laura Purdie Salas
3 years ago

The whole All Crea­tures Great and Small set was a favorite of mine as a pre-teen/­teen. I haven’t seen the new series, but I just lis­tened to ACGS audio nar­rat­ed by some­one from the new series. Fab­u­lous. I loved your tale of com­fort­ing your­self and your son with books – off to look for that par­tic­u­lar tale. I’ve read most of Her­riot’s books – but not that one!

Laura Harrison
Laura Harrison
2 years ago

The books and movies do trans­port you to a gen­tle world and while still rel­e­vant also give us a break from today’s chaos. I cer­tain­ly enjoy every eccen­tric char­ac­ter and how the sto­ries are woven togeth­er with respect and appre­ci­a­tion of all peo­ple and ani­mals. Loved your arti­cle and found you brought out the great­ness of the books and PBS series.