Magazine Parade

In the check-out line at Grand Union, I spied a mag­a­zine cov­er with kit­tens spilling out of a jack o’ lantern, the new issue of Jack and Jill. While my moth­er loaded gro­ceries from her cart onto the con­vey­or belt, a copy of the mag­a­zine rolled by as the very last item. My moth­er gave me a look. Her week­ly gro­cery bud­get didn’t include sur­pris­es. But she dug in her purse for an extra 35 cents. How could she refuse a nine-year-old who loved to read?

Jack and Jill

Like most true read­ers, I read any­thing in print, includ­ing Ladies Home Jour­nal. A mag­a­zine just for me was like find­ing fairy gold. Children’s mag­a­zines seem to fall into the cat­e­go­ry of ephemer­al mate­r­i­al, not worth exam­in­ing. A crit­i­cal paper has been writ­ten on the sub­ject, “His­tor­i­cal Overview of Children’s Mag­a­zines,” by Elaine R. Abadie. I reviewed her paper for back­ground infor­ma­tion, then root­ed in my own col­lec­tion of old children’s magazines.

Children’s peri­od­i­cals, Abadie states, reflect Amer­i­can his­to­ry and atti­tudes about youth. The Children’s Mag­a­zine, pub­lished in 1789, the year George Wash­ing­ton became pres­i­dent, was filled with moral lessons. In those days, chil­dren were meant to stay on the straight and narrow. 

St. Nicholas Illustrated Magazine for Boys and Girls

It wasn’t until 1873 when a new mag­a­zine for young peo­ple burst onto the pious scene. Edit­ed by Mary Mapes Dodge (author of Hans Brinker), St. Nicholas promised to deliv­er “the cheer of bird­song,” a place for chil­dren to play.  Con­trib­u­tors includ­ed Mark Twain, Louisa May Alcott, Rud­yard Kipling, and Frances Hodg­son Burnett.

The St. Nicholas League attract­ed sto­ries, poet­ry, and art sub­mit­ted by read­ers.  Win­ners earned badges and cash prizes. E.B. White, a win­ner him­self, wrote, “The fierce desire to write and paint that burns in our land today direct­ly trace­able to St. Nicholas.” Oth­er notable win­ners include William Faulkn­er, Rachel Car­son, and F. Scott Fitzger­ald. The mag­a­zine end­ed its hero­ic run in 1943. Some say radio may have brought about a decline in readership. 

Many mag­a­zines were pub­lished to vary­ing degrees of suc­cess. Years ago, I paid a dol­lar for an April 1908 Children’s Mag­a­zine, edit­ed by Frances Hodg­son Bur­nett. A short-lived enter­prise, my copy con­tains ads to aid “frail ane­mic chil­dren” and “healthy shoes” to pre­vent pigeon-toes.

The Brownie’s Book (1920−1921) was a noble attempt to give Black chil­dren their own mag­a­zine, designed to pro­mote “Uni­ver­sal Love and Broth­er­hood.” Spon­sored by the NAACP and edit­ed by NAACP founder W.E.B. Du Bois, it was aimed at all chil­dren, but espe­cial­ly “for the chil­dren of the Sun.” Langston Hugh­es’ first poem was pub­lished in The Brownie’s Book.

Every Child’s Mag­a­zine blew in and out like the March wind, last­ing from 1921 to 1929. At 20 cents a copy, it was prici­er than most children’s peri­od­i­cals. My copy has a love­ly Art Deco cov­er in orange and blue, with the con­tent print­ed in blue. John Martin’s The Child’s Mag­a­zine, launched in 1912, boast­ed authors such as Wan­da Gag, John­ny Gru­elle, and Thorn­ton W. Burgess. The last issue was in 1933, killed by the Depression.

Child Life

As a col­lec­tor, I found myself drawn to Child Life from 1930 to 1940, main­ly for the strik­ing cov­ers by Illi­nois illus­tra­tor Hazel Frazee. The sol­id black back­grounds and strong con­trast­ing col­ors stand out from the usu­al pas­tel offer­ings. Because Hal­loween was my favorite hol­i­day as a kid, my col­lec­tion of vin­tage children’s mag­a­zines has many Octo­ber issues.

Children's Digest and Humpty Dumpty

Jack and Jill and Hump­ty Dump­ty were my favorites grow­ing up because they were avail­able in gro­cery stores. Jack and Jill hit the stands in 1938; Hump­ty Dump­ty in 1952. Hump­ty Dump­ty was pulpy, like its sis­ter pub­li­ca­tion Children’s Digest (1950), but Jack and Jill was a bet­ter size and the paper felt right. Jack and Jill, Hump­ty Dump­ty, Children’s Digest, and Child Life were bought by the Children’s Bet­ter Health Insti­tute in 1980 and focused on health, safe­ty, nutri­tion, and exer­cise. My favorite mag­a­zine was ruined. Just sayin’.

You can’t dis­cuss children’s mag­a­zines with­out men­tion­ing High­lights for Chil­dren, begun in 1946 and still going. As a kid, I didn’t like High­lights because of its preachy fea­ture, “Goo­fus and Gal­lant.” As an adult, I’m thrilled to know High­lights fea­tured a same sex fam­i­ly in the Feb­ru­ary 2017 issue. Boy’s Life, now Scout Life, has also kept up with the times.

Children's Play Mate and Cricket Magazine

In 1973, Crick­et mag­a­zine took up the flag dropped by St. Nicholas. Edi­tor Mar­i­anne Carus declared the new pub­li­ca­tion would be “The New York­er for chil­dren.” Art direc­tor Tri­na Schart Hyman set the bar high. My Octo­ber 1974 issue lists Bet­sy Byars, Bar­bara Sleigh, Mar­jorie Shar­mat, N.M. Bodeck­er, Ann Thwaite, and Erik Bleg­vad as con­trib­u­tors. It is going strong near­ly 50 years lat­er and has expand­ed its fam­i­ly to include Baby­bug, Lady­bug, Click, Ask, Spi­der, and Muse.

A mag­a­zine I dis­cov­ered only a few years ago is The Gold­en Mag­a­zine.  It flour­ished in the 1960s, then dis­ap­peared. It had the fla­vor of Gold­en Books since it used the same illustrators. 

I still love children’s mag­a­zines. My first pub­lished sto­ry (a two-parter!) was acquired by Jack and Jill and I felt I had come home. In our house, old children’s mag­a­zines are far from for­got­ten. Sev­er­al issues of Child Life are framed as art. A rotat­ing stack of vin­tage Jack and Jill mag­a­zines sit in an old child’s wag­on as a sort of cal­en­dar. At the begin­ning of each month, I pull out a cor­re­spond­ing issue and enjoy look­ing at the cov­er every time I walk past. I’m nine years old again, slip­ping the lat­est Jack and Jill at the end of my mother’s gro­cery order.

Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Connie Van Hoven
Connie Van Hoven
11 days ago

Thank you for this delight­ful infor­ma­tion and caus­ing me to relive child­hood trips to the pediatrician’s office. The dog-eared copies of Jack and Jill made those vis­its almost enjoyable!

candice ransom
Reply to  Connie Van Hoven
10 days ago

I only remem­ber High­lights in the den­tist’s office and as a kid who read every­thing with print, it was hard not to leaf through it any­way. I did­n’t like the art (picky even at 8 and 9) and felt some of the sto­ries were too baby­ish (they cov­ered too wide an age range). But High­lights is still around and any chil­dren’s peri­od­i­cal that has stood the test of time, like Crick­et, deserves applause.

David LaRochelle
9 days ago

I loved this arti­cle, Can­dice! It brought back many fond mem­o­ries. When I was a child in the 60’s, I used to receive my neigh­bor’s sec­ond hand copies of Gold­en Mag­a­zine, which she received sec­ond hand from some­one else. I still remem­ber some of the sto­ries, and of course the jokes by Cracky, the mag­a­zine’s par­rot mascot. When I was about 10, I began receiv­ing my own sub­scrip­tion to Jack and Jill. What a thrill it was to get some­thing addressed to me in the mail! I remem­ber some of those sto­ries as well, and I bet I would rec­og­nize any cov­er from the time I was a sub­scriber. Like you, I would… Read more »

candice ransom
Reply to  David LaRochelle
9 days ago

Dave, I would have giv­en my eye-teeth for a sub­scrip­tion to Jack and Jill! Many in my col­lec­tion have mail­ing labels and I always think about the lucky kid who got that mag­a­zine each month. I sus­pect you remem­ber those cov­ers because it was rare to have a chil­dren’s mag­a­zine and you prob­a­bly read them over and over. The Gold­en Mag­a­zine, as I said, was a recent dis­cov­ery, but it’s such a classy pro­duc­tion, sort of an upscale Jack and Jill. I have read E.B. White’s essay about St. Nicholas. The roll call of St. Nicholas League prize win­ners is astonishing. I’m so glad you got your start in the… Read more »